Branstad defends vetoing university projects

2013-07-20T12:55:00Z 2013-12-06T12:13:21Z Branstad defends vetoing university projectsKATELYNN McCOLLOUGH IowaWatch Sioux City Journal

DES MOINES | Public university building projects would have a stronger chance of getting state funding if officials can show a positive economic impact for Iowa, Gov. Terry Branstad said. 

“This has been my contention from the day I took office. The universities can play a very key role in growing the Iowa economy,” Branstad said.

The governor said Iowa State University, in particular, could play a role in the economy with its agricultural, engineering and biosciences programs because they are “where the key growth is today.”

Officials at Iowa's public universities previously have argued the need a new building meets, not its economic benefit.

Branstad made his comments shortly after vetoing $7 million in project planning appropriations for three projects, one each at ISU, the University of Iowa and University of Northern Iowa. He delivered the vetoes on June 20.

People involved in planning those buildings said they were caught off guard by the vetoes. “I don’t think we had any indication that the governor was going to veto these planning appropriations,” said Warren Madden, ISU’s senior vice president for business and finance.

Branstad vetoed $2.5 million to plan a biosciences building at ISU, $3 million to plan a new pharmacy building for the UI, and $1.5 million to begin the bidding process for renovations to UNI’s Schindler Education Center.

Branstad in a recent interview said he wants to know if approving planning funds for the buildings will impact the state’s budget over the next five years. Branstad also said he wants to make sure enough money exists in the future to pay for education reform and property tax relief before starting new projects at the universities.

State regents "have capital improvement plans that go on and on and on and amount to literally hundreds and hundreds of millions of dollars. My concern is the appetite for more buildings never ends, and I guess I feel as governor I have an obligation to protect the interests of the taxpayers,” Branstad said.

Branstad spoke at length during the interview about the value of the biosciences and how much they have grown recently in Iowa, with new businesses being created in the state. Reminded that he vetoed planning funds for biosciences building at ISU, he said:

“I guess I might be interested in visiting with them more to find out what the needs are, but I don’t think we are going to lose any time especially if you do a design-build.”

A design-build approach combines the elements of design, bidding and construction to speed up the process.

The buildings remain a priority for all three universities. Each has plans to include them once again by the end of July in next year’s budget recommendations to the Board of Regents. The regents oversee Iowa’s public universities.

Madden said ISU officials would have had no issue proving the economic worth of the new biosciences building.

“Some of the products that come out of the biosciences deal with the development of new plant materials, new products that benefit Iowa and become part of the economic base for the state,” Madden said.

ISU’s new biosciences building would provide students with up-to-date laboratories and equipment, with a combination of research laboratories and teaching facilities. The university’s growing biosciences program is in five colleges, with more than 450 faculty members.

ISU puts the cost of the biosciences building at $62.5 million, with $20 million provided by private funding and $42.5 million requested from the state.

Rod Lehnertz, director of planning, designing and construction for the UI, said the Pharmacy Building in Iowa City is “programmatically and operationally one of the poorest on campus.”

He said the new building was a top priority for both the UI and the regents. Project planning already was underway before the funding was vetoed.

Lehnertz said the Pharmacy Building will cost around $90 million, with $67 million coming from the state and $25 million from private gifts and the UI.

Dwight Watson, dean of the College of Education at UNI, said the renovated Schindler Education Center, will be used to train future teachers, and allow them to interact with technology that more closely resembles what they will find when teaching in a modern classroom.

Renovations for the Schindler Education Center will cost $32 million, with all funding coming from the state.

UNI already has conducted a $26,000 feasibility study for the building.

Watson said UNI officials would need to figure out how the building’s economic benefit is measured, although there would be a long-term economic benefit by better preparing teachers, improving the education of the next generation of students.

Appropriations for the Schindler Education Center planning originally were to be $3 million, but were lowered by legislators to $1.5 million. “I personally thought that because it (the appropriation) got reduced to $1.5 million it would be easier to approve,” Watson said. “I was sort of surprised.”

Branstad’s veto message for the planning projects said the universities need to secure sustainable financing and consider changes in educational technology when deciding building needs.

“It was a last-minute deal and I just felt it made more sense to give it more thought and look at other options,” Branstad said.

All three buildings first appeared in the regents’ five-year capital plans in September 2011 and were part of the regent’s budget recommendation submitted to Branstad last fall. The regents’ five-year capital plans in 2012 included the total costs of the projects, as well as how much of those costs would come from private funding.

Senate Majority Leader Mike Gronstal, D-Council Bluffs, said talk of the projects reached the Legislature a year ago.

Gronstal said the UI’s Pharmacy Building clearly is outdated and that the Legislature should look at all three of the vetoed facilities’ broad benefits, including their economic, social and educational benefits.

The governor said he didn’t think the vetoed funding would set the building projects behind, and encouraged the universities and regents to begin using the design-build concept for the buildings to save on time and money.

Branstad approved $12 million for expansions at the ISU Research Park.

“We had a lot of indications that the research park project was a priority,” Madden said. “It certainly is more closely aligned with economic development, job creation and technology transfer, which are certainly priorities with both the Legislature and the governor.”

Copyright 2015 Sioux City Journal. All rights reserved. This material may not be published, broadcast, rewritten or redistributed.

Activate subscription button gif

Business Search

Latest Offers

View More

Featured Businesses

View More

Community Calendar

Calendar Sponsor

Top Jobs

Web Development Manager


Full-Time Opportunity

Van Drivers Needed

Need a Job?

Support Staff Openings

Truck Tire Service Personnel




Paraeducator (Teacher's Aide)


Warehouse Material Handler

Job Fair July 7

FT Veterinary Technician

Budweiser Sales Delivery Route


machine operators & maintenance


Assistant Machine Operators


Cook & Dietary Aides

Chair Rental Available

Mechanics & Service Advisor

Transfer Admissions Counselor


Insurance Inspector



Poll: Have you used all of the fireworks you purchased this year?

View Results