Federal money a factor in DHS abortion rule change decision

2012-08-03T22:00:00Z 2012-08-13T10:20:10Z Federal money a factor in DHS abortion rule change decisionBy Rod Boshart Journal Des Moines Bureau Sioux City Journal
August 03, 2012 10:00 pm  • 

DES MOINES | The potential loss of federal funding should the state halt government-funded abortions caused the head of the Iowa Department of Human Services on Friday to deny a request by 41 GOP legislators to start the process of rescinding rules governing pregnancies terminated in cases of rape, incest and fetal deformation.

“After careful review and consideration, it is my decision to deny the petition,” DHS Director Charles Palmer said in a letter to Rep. Dawn Pettengill, R-Mount Auburn, who led 41 House Republicans in seeking to severely restrict Medicaid-funded abortions in Iowa.

Palmer said legal precedent in federal decisions regarding similar situations in other states that have sought to end government-funded abortions point to the likelihood that Iowa could risk $2.1 billion in Medicaid money by pursuing that course of action.

The DHS director worried that rescinding the state’s current rules would violate federal requirements, while likely “would jeopardize all federal Medicaid funding Iowa receives, approximately $2.1 billion annually. This funding is important to the delivery of vital care to vulnerable Iowans,” he said in his letter. “I respect your deep feelings on this issue and my decision does not come lightly.”

The petition brought by the House Republicans contended that rules allowing for abortions funded via taxpayer dollars for fetuses that are physically or mentally deformed or those conceived in cases of rape or incest are illegal and should be rescinded.

According to DHS officials, federal law permits federal funds to be used for abortions to save the life of the mother or for rape or incest. In Iowa, 22 Medicaid-paid abortions were performed in fiscal 2012 – which ended Saturday, according to DHS officials. Of those, 15 were for severe fetal anomalies, five were performed to save the life of the mother, and two were for situations that involved rape. There were no requests for Medicaid payments to abort a pregnancy caused by incest.

House Democratic Leader Kevin McCarthy, D-Des Moines, praised the DHS director’s decision.

"I'm pleased Gov. Branstad put the brakes on this latest attempt by House Republicans to deny health care options to women who are victims of rape or incest,” McCarthy said in a statement. “From banning birth control such as the pill to reducing cancer screenings, this effort by Republicans was just the latest attempt in their relentless attack on women's health care.”

Likewise, Planned Parenthood of the Heartland and the American Civil Liberties Union (ACLU) of Iowa issued a joint statement applauding Palmer’s decision to deny the emergency rule-making petition.

“This petition would have put the health of Iowa women and their families at risk,” said Planned Parenthood of the Heartland President and CEO Jill June. “Thousands of Iowans rely on the Medicaid program every year. This decision ensures that those who need access to vital health care can get the services they need at a price they can afford.”

Rita Bettis, ACLU of Iowa legislative director, said the DHS made the right decision in concluding that no rule change will be made.

“The petition asked for a procedural run-around that was improper under Iowa law,” Bettis said. “It sought to withhold abortion coverage from a qualified woman. Only a woman facing those extremely difficult circumstances--not politicians--knows what decision is right for her."

There was no immediate reaction from House Republicans to Friday’s letter.

Copyright 2015 Sioux City Journal. All rights reserved. This material may not be published, broadcast, rewritten or redistributed.

Business Search

Latest Offers

View More

Featured Businesses

View More

Community Calendar

Calendar Sponsor

Top Jobs

Medical Laboratory Scientist / Med Tech

Teachers & Coaches

Insurance Inspector

Restaurant Positions

Cook for Camp Goodwill

Now Hiring

Now Hiring

Now Hiring

Maintenance, IT Draftering & More

PT Radiologic Technology Instructor

Utility/Sewer Crews

Now Hiring

Class A CDL Driver

Class A CDL Driver

Drivers Wanted

Director of Workforce Solutions

Chair Rental Available

Financial Coordinator

Now Hiring Civil Positions

Customer Assistance Professional

Coordinator of the Center for Brain & Behavior Research

PT Weekend Operator

Certified Nurse Aide (CNA) in Training

Now Hiring

Part Time Sales

Casey’s General Store - Now Hiring

Concrete foreman finisher

Now Hiring

Now Hiring

CDL Drivers

Now Hiring

Director of Child Care

Inbound Supervisor


Armored Car Security Guard

Office Assistant



Poll: Is Iowa Gov. Terry Branstad’s plan to privatize management of Medicaid a good or bad idea?

View Results