You are the owner of this article.
THROWBACK REVIEW: ‘Nightmare’ pushes animation ahead one more step

THROWBACK REVIEW: ‘Nightmare’ pushes animation ahead one more step

Jack and Zero

Jack Skellington and his ghost dog Zero deal with the horrors of the holidays in "The Nightmare Before Christmas."

Tim Burton's "The Nightmare Before Christmas" is much more than a director's vanity project.

It's the perfect bridge between cartoons and puppetry.

Shot in the stop-motion animation process, the often-scary fable shows what happens to the Pumpkin King when he journeys out of his black, white and orange world into the candy-kissed corners of Christmastown.

Enamored with its infectious rituals, the rail-thin Jack Skellington decides to introduce its best elements to the dark, depressing Halloweentown.

Folks (like the two-faced mayor) don't quite know what to make of it all.

They gamely go along with the carols, the presents and the decorations, then revert to their old selves when three kids claim the ultimate prize Santa Claus.


Halloween Town becomes a destination for Jack Skellington in "The Nightmare Before Christmas."

The rules change, "Nightmare" turns deadly, and Burton seals his fate as the most unusual filmmaker working today.

His is a macabre fairy tale that constantly teeters on the precipice of taste.

By anyone's standards, it's not for preschoolers. "Nightmare's" much too dark, far too scary.

[DVD REVIEW: Live-action "Aladdin" doesn't light up the screen.]

Teens and adults, however, will be dazzled by the artistry and roller coaster storytelling.

Written when Burton was a traditional Disney animator, "Nightmare" was dusted off and put into development after the offbeat director scored with "Batman."

Uptown Theater
Iowa Theater
Riviera Theater
Hollywood Theater
Hipp Theater

Eager to get him into their stable, Disney execs agreed to give Burton artistic control. Instead of pushing pencil animation, he opted for the doll-like stop-motion process.

The result is a small step for Burton, a giant leap for animation.


Sally has deep affection for Jack Skellington in "The Nightmare Before Christmas."

"Nightmare" kicks open the door "Who Framed Roger Rabbit" cracked and gives creators like director Henry Selick an all-access pass to Hollywood's inner sanctum.

It follows the Grinch game plan perhaps too closely for its own good, but gets great yardage out of tweaking holiday traditions.

Jack's ghost dog Zero does a delicious send-up of Rudolph; his squeeze, Sally, has the heart to turn a seasonal experiment into a valuable life lesson.

[Throwback: The Journal's review of "Back to the Future, Part II."]

It mesmerizes throughout and gives Disney a set of characters just ripe for theme park adaptation. The skeletal Jack may sing like he's auditioning for "Phantom of the Opera,' but moves' like he' an anorexic Tommy Tune. When he drops into the arms of a cement angel, Burton approaches Michelangelo and "Nightmare" becomes much more than a holiday diversion.

While the film may never rival "Aladdin" terms of box office clout, it has the timelessness to be around for decades.

Thanks to Burton's eye, Selick's care and Elfman's essence, it's a classic that's long on class.

This review ran in the Oct. 29, 1993 edition of The Journal.


Get Breaking News delivered directly to you.

* I understand and agree that registration on or use of this site constitutes agreement to its user agreement and privacy policy.

Related to this story

Get up-to-the-minute news sent straight to your device.


News Alerts

Breaking News