You are the owner of this article.
Elmi Said found guilty of voluntary manslaughter in Sioux City stabbing death
breaking top story

Elmi Said found guilty of voluntary manslaughter in Sioux City stabbing death

Elmi Said murder trial

Elmi Said, left, talks with defense attorney Brian Buckmeier on Sept. 4 during the first day of evidence in his murder trial in Woodbury County District Court. Jurors on Wednesday found Said guilty of voluntary manslaughter for the Oct. 28 stabbing death of Guled Nur at the Phoenix Apartments in Sioux City.

SIOUX CITY -- After spending eight hours discussing the case, jurors on Wednesday found Elmi Said guilty of voluntary manslaughter for the fatal stabbing of his roommate last fall.

Said showed little visible reaction to the verdict, which carries a shorter prison term than he had faced when his trial began a week ago in Woodbury County District Court.

A Class C felony, voluntary manslaughter carries a 10-year prison sentence, compared with the 50 years Said would have received had jurors convicted him of his original charge of second-degree murder.

District Judge Patrick Tott scheduled sentencing for Nov. 1.

[Read more: Sioux City man sentenced to 50 years in prison for stabbing another man to death.]

Said, of Sioux City, fatally stabbed Guled Nur on Oct. 28 in the doorway of their apartment. Surveillance camera video shown at trial showed Nur take a few steps down the hallway of the Phoenix Apartments, 1003 Pierce St., before collapsing. He later died at MercyOne Siouxland Medical Center.

Three women and a man in attendance for the verdict said through a representative they did not wish to comment on the jury's decision. It was not clear if the four were friends or relatives of Said or Nur.

The nine women and three men on the jury received the case at about 11 a.m. Tuesday after listening to three days of testimony. After not reaching a verdict Tuesday, they returned at 9 a.m. Wednesday, reaching their verdict at about noon.

Said, a native of Somalia who had become a U.S. citizen, testified in his own defense that he was acting in self-defense after Nur, who also was from Somalia, threatened to kill him with a knife because Said did not share his beer with him. Said also said he was scared of Nur because of an incident five days earlier in which Nur had threatened to kill him with a knife after Said refused to let him eat food he had prepared for his lunch the following day.

Said's former wife, Fatumo Abdi, testified that Nur, who lived with them, had been drinking beer and cinnamon-flavored whisky all day and that they were both drunk when Said came home from work about 10 p.m. She said that Said drank with a neighbor in another apartment, and then went home before he and Nur got into the argument over the beer. Abdi said that after Nur threatened Said with a knife, Said went to the kitchen and returned with something in his hand, but she was too drunk to determine what it was. Abdi ran from the apartment and did not see the altercation that led to the stabbing.


Sign up for our Crime & Courts newsletter

* I understand and agree that registration on or use of this site constitutes agreement to its user agreement and privacy policy.

Related to this story

Eliot Stowe was arrested Nov. 20 and charged with murder, months after Cheryl Stowe's body was found wrapped in a rug in a well-hidden area near her home on June 27, 2018, a day after co-workers had contacted authorities to check on her because she had not shown up for work.

Get up-to-the-minute news sent straight to your device.


News Alerts

Breaking News