
Luna, a 9-month-old spayed pit bull, sits with a tug toy at the Siouxland Humane Society's Sioux City shelter in 2014. Sioux City Council members voted Monday to overturn a controversial 11-year-old ban on pit bulls within city limits.
SIOUX CITY -- Sioux City Council members voted Monday to overturn a controversial 11-year-old ban on pit bulls within city limits. The repeal of the ban becomes effective on Saturday.
The ban, which was sponsored by former Councilman Aaron Rochester and unanimously adopted in September 2008, prohibited residents from having dogs that are 51 percent or more pit bull. Although no new pit bulls were allowed under the ban, it grandfathered in pit bulls that were registered by residents prior to April 25, 2009, provided the animals were registered each year.

Capron
After the 4-1 vote to adopt an ordinance that would repeal the ban, the packed council chamber erupted in applause. But it was Councilwoman Rhonda Capron's comments that received a standing ovation from the majority of those in attendance.
Capron said she had been called "scum and worse" during the time that the council was weighing overturning the ban. Capron, who earlier this month lost her bid for a third four-year term to first-time candidate Julie Schoenherr, came under fire from people who felt she should've abstained from voting on the issue because she owns a pit bull mix that was grandfathered in. Jim Rixner, who was a member of the council that enacted the pit bull ban, wrote that Capron had "a conflict of interest" in a letter to the editor that was published on Oct. 20 in the Journal.Â
"I've been called out in the HyVee parking lot, through emails, texts, phone calls and even in the Sioux City Journal Sunday editorial page twice by Jim Rixner," Capron read from prepared remarks. "He had the audacity to call a city councilwoman, me, a gangbanger or a wannabe-gangbanger because I own a pit bull mix. Shame on you Jim Rixner."

Rixner
When reached by phone Monday night, Rixner said he never referred to Capron as a gangbanger or a gang member.Â
"She's a good person. I think she's done a good job representing the City Council and the city," he said. "I tried not to attack her in any shape or form."
At an Oct. 21 council meeting, Rixner said he was concerned about pit bulls returning to the city in the wrong hands.Â
"The problem is 10 percent of us people who are drug owners will have pit bulls again. The problem is the 10 to 15 percent gangbangers or want-to-be gangbangers that will bring their pit bulls back," Rixner said during that meeting.
The city's legal department recommended that the council adopt an ordinance to lift the ban because animal control regulations across the country are "turning to breed neutral regulation and moving away from breed specific regulations." The repeal was also recommended to ensure future compliance with Americans with Disabilities Act and Fair Housing Act regulations for individuals who may have service animals that fall under breed specific regulation.
The council voted 4 to 1 on Oct. 14 to move forward an ordinance that would repeal the ban. Then, a week later, the council voted 3 to 2 in favor of the ordinance on second consideration.
Just as he did on first and second consideration, Councilman Pete Groetken, a retired Sioux City Police captain, voted against repealing the ban on final consideration.
You have free articles remaining.
Citing statistics that he received, Groetken said canines killed 471 Americans from 2005 to 2018. He said pit bulls contributed to 66 percent or 311 of those deaths. In 2018, alone, nearly 27,000 people underwent reconstructive surgery as the result of being bitten by dogs, according to Groetken. He said the average cost of a dog bite-related hospital stay was $18,200.

Groetken
"When we get to the point to where the severity and the fatalities don't bother us and we're more worried about the amount of money we're going to save, I think we've gone down the wrong path," he said.
Preston Moore, Iowa state director for the Humane Society of the United States, said the American Veterinary Medical Association and the Centers for Disease Control and Prevention examined the statistics and came to the conclusion that the deaths "were not because the dogs were pit bulls."
Judy Grimsley, president of the Siouxland Humane Society, thanked the council for revisiting the ban and said that every dog should be treated on its own merits and behaviors.
Resident Raylee Hudson said she had to have a dog put down because of the ban. Under the ordinance, a pit bull was described as an American pit bull terrier, American Staffordshire terrier, Staffordshire bull terrier or any dog that looks like or has characteristics of being one of those breeds.
"It wasn't even a pit bull itself. It was an American Bulldog," she said through tears. "I don't think this breed of dog should be put to sleep just because of the way it looks or because of how one person wants to raise their dog."
Councilman Dan Moore said the ordinance banning pit bulls "might be indefensible" in court. He suggested that the city form an advisory committee of citizens to oversee animal control.
If the ban was kept in place, Mayor Bob Scott said the city could spend $200,000 of taxpayers' money trying to defend a lawsuit it knows it can't win.
"Sometimes, you gotta cut your losses whether you like it or not; and that's where I'm at today," he said.
The council also voted to approve an ordinance that revises animal control chapters of the City Code, including pet licensing fees and the leash law.
The annual licensing fee for neutered dogs and cats will increase from $11 to $15, but the fee for unneutered cats will remain at the current amount of $31 per year. The licensing fee for unneutered dogs will rise from $31 to $50.
Revisions to the leash law eliminate the option of having an animal under voice control. An animal that is "at large," is defined as any licensed or unlicensed animal found off the premises of its owner and not under the control of a person physically capable of controlling the animal on a leash 16 feet or less in length.
Date booked: 11/20/2019. Charge: possession of a non-marijuana controlled substance. Bond amount: $2,000.
Date booked: 11/20/2019. Charges: possession of methamphetamine with intent to deliver, drug tax stamp, felony eluding, possession of marijuana, driving while barred, theft 2nd. Bond amount: $18,000.
Date booked: 11/20/2019. Charges: possession of drug paraphernalia, simple eluding, operating without owners consent. Bond amount: $2,600.
Date booked: 11/20/2019. Charge: probation violation. Bond amount: $1,000.
Date booked: 11/19/2019. Charges: probation violations, hold for South Dakota. Bond amount: $4,000.
Date booked: 11/19/2019. Charges: driving the wrong way, driving with expired registration, no drivers license, no vehicle insurance, open container, furnishing controlled substance to an inmate, hold for ICE. Bond amount: $6,500.
Date booked: 11/19/2019. Charges: driving while barred, no vehicle insurance. Bond amount: $3,000.
Date booked: 11/19/2019. Charge: parole violation. Bond amount: $20,000.
Date booked: 11/19/2019. Charges: possession of methamphetamine with intent to deliver, hold for Iowa. Bond amount: $25,000.
Date booked: 11/19/2019. Charges: burglary, theft. Bond amount: $10,000.
Date booked: 11/19/2019. Charges: possession of methamphetamine with intent to deliver, possession of marijuana, possession of drug paraphernalia, drug tax stamp, failure to display license plate. Bond amount: $25,000.
Date booked: 11/18/2019. Charge: serious domestic assault. Bond amount: $2,000.
Date booked: 11/18/2019. Charge: OWI. Bond amount: $2,000.
Date booked: 11/18/2019. Charge: no contact order. Bond amount: $1,000.
Date booked: 11/18/2019. Charges: OWI, driving while barred, driving with suspended license, operating without registration. Bond amount: $5,000.
Date booked: 11/18/2019. Charges: probation violation, carrying weapon, false report. Bond amount: $1,500.
Date booked: 11/18/2019. Charges: possession of methamphetamine with intent to deliver possession of drug paraphernalia, drug tax stamp, insufficient number of highlights. Bond amount: $20,000.
Date booked: 11/18/2019. Charges: no drivers license, contempt of court, simple false report. Bond amount: $2,900.
Date booked: 11/17/2019. Charges: burglary, operating without owners consent, failure to comply with court order, theft, probation violation, hold for South Dakota. Bond amount: $21,000.
Date booked: 11/17/2019. Charges: OWI. Bond amount: $2,000.
Date booked: 11/16/2019. Charges: probation violations. Bond amount: $10,000.
Date booked: 11/16/2019. Charges: parole violation, felon in possession of a firearm, possession of a non-marijuana controlled substance, serious domestic assault. Bond amount: $26,000.
Date booked: 11/16/2019. Charges: trafficking stolen firearms, theft, probation violation. Bond amount: $11,000.
Date booked: 11/16/2019. Charges: serious police assault, criminal mischief, child endangerment, public intoxication. Bond amount: $5,000.
Date booked: 11/15/2019. Charge: parole violation. Bond amount: $20,000.
Date booked: 11/15/2019. Charges: possession of drugs, criminal trespass. Bond amount: $1,000.
Date booked: 11/15/2019. Charge: possession of marijuana. Bond amount: $1,000.
Date booked: 11/15/2019. Charge: probation violation. Bond amount: $5,000.
Date booked: 11/15/2019. Charges: OWI, child endangerment, no vehicle insurance. Bond amount: $4,000.
Date booked: 11/15/2019. Charges: absence from custody, convict mittimus. Bond amount: $1,000.
Date booked: 11/15/2019. Charges: possession of methamphetamine with intent to deliver, drug tax stamp, possession of marijuana, driving with suspended license, drug possession. Bond amount: $6,000.
Date booked: 11/15/2019. Charge: probation violation. Bond amount: $1,000.
Date booked: 11/14/2019. Charge: no contact order. Bond amount: $3,000.
Date booked: 11/14/2019. Charges: possession of drugs, failure to comply with court order, theft. Bond amount: $2,000.
Date booked: 11/14/2019. Charges: parole violation, hold for Iowa. Bond amount: $20,300.
Date booked: 11/14/2019. Charges: OWI, driving with revoked license, no vehicle insurance, operating without registration, serious eluding, hold for Nebraska. Bond amount: $4,000.
Date booked: 11/14/2019. Charges: convict mittimus, hold for South Dakota. Bond amount: $1,000.
Date booked: 11/13/2019. Charges: probation violation, OWI, driving while barred. Bond amount: $6,000.
Date booked: 11/13/2019. Charge: parole violation. Bond amount: $20,000.
Date booked: 11/13/2019. Charge: parole violation. Bond amount: $20,000.
Date booked: 11/13/2019. Charge: parole violation. Bond amount: $20,000.
Indecent Exposure Burger

An Indecent Exposure Burger is shown Thursday, March 15, 2018, at Krause's Main Street Burgers in Hinton, Iowa. The burger featured a one-pound burger patty, ham, bacon and cheese.
Spiked Bulleit Bourbon Burger

Have you ever needed a photo ID when ordering a burger? Served with Kentucky bourbon whiskey, Bar Louie's Spiked Bulleit Bourbon Burger is only available for customers age 21 and over.
Taste food truck

Malon Downs and his son, Elijah, cook hamburgers Friday, July 6, 2018, at the Taste food truck during Food Truck Friday in downtown Sioux City.
Taste's island burger

Taste's Island Burger comes topped with pineapple slices and a pineapple chipotle sauce.
Brightside Burger

Chef Sarah Byers plates a Brightside Burger inside the kitchen at the Brightside Cafe and Deli in May 2018.
Prime Rib Melt

Madonna Rose Cafe's Prime Rib Melt is an elevated version of a Patty Melt. Instead of the traditional hamburger patty, this meaty sandwich is made with shaved slice of prime rib.
Clyde's Burger

Chef Horacio Ochoa of Clyde's Grill & Pub poses for a photo with a steakhouse burger in Sioux City on Thursday, March 1, 2018.
Big Daddy burger

A Big Daddy bacon cheese burger is shown at Sugar Daddy's in North Sioux City on Aug. 27, 2015.
Key Club Steakhouse Burger

Made with blue cheese crumbles, sauteed onions, mushrooms, bacon, truffle oil and steak sauce, 1008 Key Club's Steakhouse Burger gives a unique spin to traditional bar food.
Salvage Yard Challenge

Owner Joe Junck displays the two-pound hamburger patty used in the Salvage Yard Challenge prior to cooking at Junkyard Pub 'N Grub in Hinton, Iowa, on Sept. 9, 2017.
McDonald's Bacon Smokehouse

McDonald's Bacon Smokehouse Burger gets its "smokiness" was featured in a Weekender taste test.
Wheelhouse BBQ bacon burger

Served with house-made chips, The Wheelhouse Bar & Grill's BBQ Bacon burger has a seared beef patty, Applewood bacon, a creamy cole slaw and haystack onion strips inside a toasted Brioche bun.
Village Idiot burger

The Village Idiot Burger is seen at Castle Pub & Grill in Sioux City on May 12, 2017.Â
Main + Abbey pub burger

The Main + Abbey pub burger, shown in April 2017, is made with a house-ground patty, shallots, Cambozola cheese, kale, heirloom tomatoes and a cracked pepper and Parmesan aioli on a Kaiser roll.
Mad Town Booga

Topped with slow-roasted corned beef, crispy fried onions, Thousand Island dressing and your choice of cheese, the Mad Town Booga is one of the creatively named Angus beef burgers available at Tanner's Bar & Grill.
P’s Big Beefy Burger

P's Pizza House's Big Beefy Burger, shown here in January 2017, is topped with roast beef, provolone cheese, a fried onion and a tangy bistro sauce.
Gud n Free

The house burger is seen at Gud n Free in Sioux City on July 12, 2016.
George's burger

Lola Reinert, 7, eats a hamburger at George's Hot Dog Shop in Sioux City on June 15, 2016.
Woudstra Meat Market

Chad Borchers, smokehouse manager at Woudstra Meat Market, stacks the hamburger patties in Orange City, Iowa, on April 7, 2016.
South Sioux City Hy-Vee

Tim Schieull, store director of the South Sioux City Hy-Vee, grills hamburgers during the Law Enforcement Appreciation Tailgate Party prior to the Morningside-Briar Cliff football game in 2015.Â
Ickey Nickel burgers

Burgers at Ickey Nickel Bar & Grill, from top, lasagna burger, jalapeno burger, and bacon and cheese burger, are seen July 24, 2015.
Jalapeno pepperjack stuffed burger

Ickey Nickel Bar & Grill cook Kenny Crampton said his jalapeno pepperjack-stuffed burger, shown in 2015, was acquiring plenty of fans.
Jolly Rogers anchor burger

Served with lettuce, tomato, onions, pickles and cheese, the Anchor Burger iswas among Jolly Rogers' most popular menu items, manager Nick Long said in a 2015 interview.
Pop-N-Docs

Alex Jank cooks a hamburger at Pop-N-Docs in Decatur, Neb in 2015.
Lue's Cheeseburger

A Lue's Cheeseburger is shown in 2015 at The Ritz at Arnolds Park, which brought it out of retirement from the former Lue's Driftwood in Okoboji.Â
Clyde's steakhouse burger

A steakhouse burger at Clyde's Pub and Grill is pictured April 18, 2014, in Sioux City.
Cody's Homestead

Cody's Homestead cook Crystal Monk retrieves a chicken fillet to place on the homemade hamburger bun at the restaurant in Elk Point, South Dakota on March 6, 2014.
Minervas veggie burger

A veggie burger with whole grain chips is shown at Minerva's in Sioux City in 2013.
Fair burgers

Grant Streck, of Moville, Iowa, serves a sample of his Best in Show no-mess mushroom and Swiss hamburgers during a cookout contest at the Woodbury County Fair in 2013.
Kahill's Wagyu Burger

Seen in 2013 is the Wagyu Burger by executive chef Ryan Devitt at Kahill's Chophouse in South Sioux City.
Red Bones Burger

A Red Bones Burger is served up at Red Bones Café in Sioux City on May 17, 2013.
Iowa Cattlemen's Association

Ted Paulsrud and Kevin Carstensen of the Iowa Cattlemen's Association, cook hamburgers at the Tyson Events Center in 2012.
Picnic burger

Jaiden Beaulieu, 9, Sioux City, bites into a hamburger during a free public picnic featuring burgers made with the Lean Finely Textured Beef from BPI at the Tyson Events Center parking lot in March 2012.
Rick Perry burger

Then-Texas Gov. Rick Perry eats a hamburger made with lean finely textured beef following a press conference March 29, 2012, in South Sioux City. The press conference was held to defend Beef Products Inc's. lean finely textured beef product.
Iron Hill burger

This 2012 photo shows a barbecue burger at Iron Hill Bar & Grill, located in Sioux City's Southern Hills Mall.
Labor Day Picnic

Wendell Shearer puts ketchup on his hamburger on Sept. 5, 2011, as part of the Northwest Iowa Labor Council Labor Day picnic at Riverside Park.
Town House burger

Kerrie Curry, owner of Curry's Town House Cafe on Dakota Avenue in South Sioux City is pictured in 2011 showing off a Town House burger and fries.
Clyde's Grill and Pub

A burger and fries at Clyde's Grill and Pub are shown in this 2011 photo.
Dugout Bar and Grill

Michelle Kane, a cook at The Dugout Bar & Grill in Ute, Iowa, prepares burgers, fries and specials like pan fried chicken during lunch hour on March 24, 2011.
Tailgate food

Ponca High School boosters Tracy Anderson, right and Dan Krause flip burgers for hungry game fans prior to a game against Hartington Cedar Catholic on Sept. 23, 2010, in Ponca, Neb.
Morningside College food

Morningside College food service employees Erik Totman and Tammi Left are shown in 2010 making hamburgers and other food items at the college's dining hall.