Skip to main content
You are the owner of this article.
You have permission to edit this article.
Sioux City School Board could again shift public comment portion in meetings
top story

Sioux City School Board could again shift public comment portion in meetings


SIOUX CITY -- After the most recent change 18 months ago, the Sioux City School Board could again be moving the time when people can speak on any issue of concern during the public comment portion of meetings.

In the last two board meetings in November, people urged school board members to move the public comment portion from the end of the meetings to the beginning.

In the first of those two meetings, a parent, Mike Bushby, who lives in the 2300 block of Seneca Way, used the public comment period to assert that the beginning of meetings was a better time for people to weigh in on school topics. Bushby was followed by Dan Greenwell, a longtime district administration critic, who said he agreed with placing the public comment period earlier in meeting agenda.

Greenwell was the school board candidate who got the most votes of six people in the Nov. 5 election for four board positions. He was sworn in as a board member on Nov. 25, when departing board member David Gleiser in some of his final remarks also urged the continuing board members to have public comment at both the beginning and end of each meeting, as has been done in recent years in weekly Tuesday meetings of the Woodbury County Board of Supervisors.

Board president Jeremy Saint told Gleiser that any change would best be addressed by the district's Policy Review Committee with a recommendation to board members. In June 2018, the school board shifted from having had public comment at the beginning of meetings.

At the time, Saint said the change was approved by the board after the Policy Review Committee worked through the proposal. Saint said board member Perla Alarcon-Flory asked about moving the citizen concerns to the end of the meeting, largely because several people spoke early about items that were on the agenda later in the meeting. Saint said many people then left before the board actually took up the agenda item for the fuller, planned discussion.

The school board meetings typically begin at 6 p.m. on Mondays twice per month, and it is not unusual for meetings to last two or more hours.

Support Local Journalism

Your membership makes our reporting possible.

On Wednesday, Greenwell said the best reason to have public comment at the beginning of the meetings is to lessen the wait for people to discuss issues of concern. He also said the public comment period was moved to the end of meetings in order to lessen the likelihood that people bring concerns to the board.

Each person is given up to 5 minutes to speak, with a clock projected on a screen counting down the time.

Over the last year, the process has been more formalized, as people are asked to fill out a one-page form with their name, address and concern, plus whether "your concern (has) been presented to the superintendent previously?"

One other factor with public comment portions is that board members don't answer the issues or questions raised  by the speaker. As Saint explained in the most recent meeting, that doesn't mean the board members don't care about the issue, but they are not to engage in discussions, since the item isn't on the agenda.

The Iowa Public Information Board summary of Chapters 21 and 22 of the Iowa code says, "Government bodies are not required to allow public comment at open meetings, though many do, and they are allowed to enforce reasonable rules to ensure meetings are orderly." However, nothing in the law precludes elected officials from responding to public comments.

Greenwell, who has posed many questions in the last few years during public comment periods, said it is time that board members give people answers.

He said there is nothing unlawful about board members asking clarifying questions and giving comments, so long as no deliberations or decisions are being made. Greenwell said that's how the Iowa City School Board handles public comment periods.

"I think we will get that changed," he said.


Get Government & Politics updates in your inbox!

* I understand and agree that registration on or use of this site constitutes agreement to its user agreement and privacy policy.

Related to this story

Get up-to-the-minute news sent straight to your device.


News Alerts

Breaking News