A top child welfare watchdog called Thursday for Nebraska to end its contract with the Kansas nonprofit managing the cases of abused and neglected children in the Omaha area.
Inspector General of Nebraska Child Welfare Jennifer Carter made the recommendation in a special report looking at the contract with Saint Francis Ministries and at the state's history of privatized case management in Douglas and Sarpy counties.
The report found that the private contractor has failed to meet key terms of its contract with the Nebraska Department of Health and Human Services for nearly two years. The problems include its failure to meet state mandated caseload limits for workers, failure to meet monthly with children in care and failure to document case plans within 60 days.
"Saint Francis has failed to do its job in consequential ways that affect children and families," Carter said. "The state should not continue to spend millions of public dollars on this contract when Saint Francis is not meeting its terms.”
She also recommended that Nebraska end its 12-year experiment with having private contractors manage child welfare cases, saying the effort has been unsuccessful. The report said it has yielded no measurable improvement and demonstrated unacceptable risk.
"The pilot project has demonstrated the significant risk of disruption, instability, and financial uncertainty inherent in the privatization of child welfare case management," the report said. "Saint Francis’ performance brought these risks into starker relief."
The inspector general's office was created as part of the Legislature's response to earlier problems with the privatization effort.
Nebraska began a disastrous attempt to privatize the oversight of child welfare cases statewide in 2009. The effort was plagued with turmoil, and four of the five original contractors ended up dropping or losing their contracts within two years.
The sole survivor of the effort was PromiseShip, an Omaha-based agency that started out as the Nebraska Families Collaborative. It held the contract to manage metro-area cases for nearly a decade, until the contract was rebid in 2019.
Saint Francis won the bid in July 2019 by offering to do the job for $197 million over five years, less than 60% of the bid from PromiseShip. During the bid review, PromiseShip outscored Saint Francis on all areas except cost.
However, Nebraska ended up signing a new, emergency contract with Saint Francis in late January after interim Saint Francis CEO William Clark told state lawmakers that the agency would run out of money to operate unless Nebraska agreed to pay more. The 25-month, $147.3 million contract increased payments to the same level as PromiseShip had bid.
The emergency contract ends Feb. 28, 2023, a month after Gov. Pete Ricketts is term-limited out of office. Under state law, the contract could be extended for another year. Any other decision would require months of lead time to allow for a gradual transition of cases and a possible rebidding of the contract.
The bonuses were described as hazard pay for the 50 or so employees of Morrill County in the Nebraska Panhandle. Residents had mixed views on whether the bonuses were a good way to spend the relief funds.